Mostly yes. A median Dallas home sells for about $461,000; Philadelphia, about $275,000. Dallas pairs no state income tax with a 1.45% county property rate and about $3,489 a year in insurance; Philadelphia pairs a flat 3.07% state tax and a 3.735% resident wage tax with a 0.82% rate and about $1,500. Income, home price, and commute decide the winner.
I'm Craig Lerch, a broker at eXp Realty who runs relocation searches across the Philadelphia metro, and a Dallas move is one I see every season. Everything here was verified in November 2026 against Redfin sale data, the Tax Foundation property tax tables, Pennsylvania and Philadelphia tax pages, U.S. Energy Information Administration rates, the Texas Department of Insurance, and NOAA climate normals. Rates and prices move; confirm the numbers for the address and tax year in front of you.
The two cities, column by column
The headline is the house. Redfin's October 2026 citywide medians for the three months ending that month read about $461,000 in Dallas and about $275,000 in Philadelphia, so the entry price to a typical home there runs about 40% lower here (Redfin, verified November 2026). Every other column narrows that gap, and two of them, income tax and winter heating, run the other way.
- Home price: about $461,000 Dallas citywide median versus about $275,000 Philadelphia (Redfin).
- State income tax: none in Texas; a flat 3.07% in Pennsylvania on wages, interest, dividends, and capital gains (PA Department of Revenue).
- City wage tax: Philadelphia charges residents 3.735% and non-residents working in the city 3.425% from July 1, 2026; Dallas has none (City of Philadelphia).
- Property tax: effective rates of about 1.45% in Dallas County and about 0.82% in Philadelphia County; median owner-occupied bills about $4,798 versus $2,003 (Tax Foundation, 2024 data).
- Homeowners insurance: Texas statewide average about $3,489 a year for 2025; Pennsylvania roughly $1,400 to $2,200 (Texas Department of Insurance; insurance.com, MoneyGeek).
- Electricity: about 15.9 cents per kWh in Texas versus 21.8 cents in Pennsylvania (U.S. EIA, August 2026); Philly's PECO price-to-compare ran 11.759 cents, supply only (PECO).
- Sales tax: 8.25% in Dallas versus 8.0% in Philadelphia, a near tie (state revenue departments).
The property tax machine is the quiet difference
The state averages hide the mechanic. Texas property tax is high because there is no state income tax to soften it: the Tax Foundation's 2026 table (2024 data) puts Texas at 1.40% average effective and Pennsylvania at 1.26%, but the counties a mover actually compares sit further apart, Dallas County at about 1.45% effective with a median annual bill of about $4,798, Philadelphia County at about 0.82% with about $2,003 (verified November 2026).
The rules around the bill differ as much as the rate. Texas caps the appraised value of a residence homestead at a 10% annual rise (Texas Tax Code section 23.23) and adds homestead exemptions, so a long-held house bills against a value well below market. Pennsylvania resets nothing at the moment of sale: most suburban counties stay on a base year until a countywide reassessment, so the assessed value on your first bill can sit well below your price, and two similar houses on one block can carry two different assessments (verified November 2026). Philadelphia instead runs periodic citywide reassessments, so a recent sale is more likely to bill near contract. Philadelphia's $100,000 Homestead Exemption against assessed value is not automatic, you file it, and it typically cuts about $1,400 off an annual bill at the current 1.3998% rate (phila.gov, verified November 2026).
Income tax: where the Texas assumption breaks
Texas has no state income tax, and Pennsylvania taxes a resident's income at a flat 3.07% with no brackets and no standard deduction, reaching wages paid by an out-of-state employer because the liability follows residency, not the employer's address. Inside the city the resident wage tax adds 3.735% (3.425% for non-resident commuters), withheld from your first paycheck even when your employer's headquarters is in Texas (PA Department of Revenue; City of Philadelphia; verified November 2026). On $100,000 of wages with no other income, the Philadelphia-resident stack is about $3,070 in state tax plus $3,735 in wage tax, roughly $6,805 a year that Dallas would not collect. The rates are scheduled to decline through 2030 under a five-year plan adopted in June 2025; the suburb-by-suburb wage tax picture is in the posts linked at the bottom.
The lines most Dallas movers fear do not follow the fear. The wage tax applies only to earned compensation, and Pennsylvania exempts retirement income: Social Security, pensions, and qualifying 401(k), 403(b), and IRA distributions are not taxed by the state (verified November 2026). A retiree moving from Dallas keeps the $0 state tax on retirement income; a working household most likely does not. Texas levies nothing on your income after the move, so there is no second state return and no credit to chase; have a CPA run the exact year before you set a budget.
Insurance and electricity: the monthly lines that flip
Homeowners insurance is where the Dallas premium shrinks. The Texas Department of Insurance puts the 2025 statewide average at about $3,489 a year, up from $2,124 in 2021, driven by hail and wind, roughly 62% of losses since 2019, under file-and-use rules that let rates rise before review. Pennsylvania averages run about $1,400 to $2,200 (insurance.com, MoneyGeek, verified November 2026). The same coverage is typically half the Texas price, and you can drop the wind and hail deductible habit. Flood insurance follows FEMA flood maps in both states, a per-address question, not a state average.
Electricity is the reverse: Pennsylvania's per-kWh price runs about 21.8 cents against Texas's 15.9 cents (U.S. EIA, August 2026), but the load flips. Dallas averages about 20 days a year at 100 degrees or hotter; Philadelphia, fewer than one. Philadelphia instead averages about 4,759 heating degree days a year against Dallas's 2,218 (NOAA 1991-2020 normals). The cooling season you ran all summer becomes a heating season that runs about five months a year, and much of the older city stock heats with gas radiators instead of central air; the winter heating post at the bottom puts real numbers on that bill.
Sales tax is a tie, and the cars are the sleeper
Dallas charges 8.25% combined state, city, and transit sales tax; Philadelphia charges 8.0% (6% state plus 2% local), so the checkout price is close to a wash and the famous 6% does not apply inside the city (verified November 2026). The sleeper column is the car. Dallas households need at least one; Philadelphia households in the walkable core can run zero, and the difference is everything attached to the car, not the payment: insurance, parking priced annually in permit districts, and the rest. The car-free, parking, and insurance posts below turn that column into numbers.
How it differs across the metro
Those columns are the city of Philadelphia. Move to a suburban Pennsylvania county and the resident wage tax disappears; you owe your municipality's local earned income tax instead, typically about 1%, plus the city's 3.425% only if you commute into Philadelphia. Cross into New Jersey or Delaware and the wage tax applies only if you work in the city, while property tax and transfer fees sit at their own county numbers. The one constant is the inversion a Texan has to unlearn: the Philadelphia city median runs below every collar county, where the Dallas city median runs near the top of the metro. The wage tax and NJ-versus-PA posts cover both full tables.
What most people get wrong
- That no state income tax makes Texas cheaper. The bundle is the bill: on the two median houses, Texas property and insurance alone run about $8,300 a year against roughly $3,500 in Philadelphia, before the mortgage.
- That Pennsylvania's 6% sales tax beats Texas at checkout. Philadelphia adds 2% locally, so it is 8.0% against 8.25%, a tie.
- That a Pennsylvania bill tracks your sale price. Base-year counties do not reassess at sale at all, Philadelphia's reassessments can bill above, at, or below contract, and the Homestead Exemption only exists if you file it.
- That retirement income starts getting taxed in Pennsylvania. It does not: Social Security, pensions, and qualifying plan and IRA distributions are exempt, so the retiree's state rate on retirement income is 0% in both states.
If you're coming from Dallas
What genuinely surprises a Dallas mover is not the tax table, it is what the housing does. The price inversion, city under suburbs, is the opposite of DFW. A large share of the older stock has no central air, so the house asks for window units and a radiator system, and the winter gas bill replaces the summer cooling bill. A car is optional in the core, and parking, not fuel, is its real cost. Homeowners insurance falls by more than half. And the thing no national relocation listicle prints is the assessment detail: on a suburban Pennsylvania purchase, your first bill can be computed on an assessed value that has nothing to do with your contract price, so pull the parcel's assessment before you set the monthly number, and budget for the county's next reassessment as a known future event.
Your next step
Turn it into a shortlist: the neighborhood-criteria worksheet scores blocks on the columns that differ, price per square foot, tax at the parcel, commute, parking, utilities, insurance, and schools. Email [EMAIL] or book 20 minutes at [CALENDAR LINK].
Related reading
- Moving from Texas to Philadelphia: the lifestyle file to read beside the money columns
- Do I pay Philly's wage tax if I live in the suburbs?
- How much does it cost to heat a house in Philadelphia?
- Is it cheaper to live in Philadelphia or the suburbs?
- Center City: the walkable high-rise core
- The Main Line: suburban prices that run above the city